≈ the.bay.news

EPP tabled 248 omnibus amendments weakening privacy, noyb finds

programming.dev
EPP tabled 248 omnibus amendments weakening privacy, noyb finds
> This article was published in October 2026, but I haven’t seen anything about this in the last few weeks since it was published. > > It is quite ironic given the statement on their homepage [https://www.epp.eu/?v=1.0.24]: > > > Every day, renewing the trust of the European citizens is the driving inspiration for the EPP’s activities. > > > The EPP are by far the largest party in the EU [https://facts-and-figures.europarl.europa.eu/snapshot/term-10/current#MEPs-and-political-groups-by-country], and are quite a lot bigger than the party closest in to them in terms of size, and they currently in the most governments in the EU either in coalition or leading. > > LIST OF EPP REPRESENTATION IN EACH COUNTRY [https://www.epp.eu/parties-and-partners/] > > *** > > [https://europe.pub/api/v3/image_proxy?url=https%3A%2F%2Flemmy.ml%2Fapi%2Fv3%2Fimage_proxy%3Furl%3Dhttps%253A%252F%252Ffeddit.uk%252Fpictrs%252Fimage%252Fa022bd7c-dfa5-4cbd-a651-037ab3376d3d.webp] > > Navy-suited MEPs snip a privacy umbrella as noyb finds EPP tabled 248 amendments weakening the GDPR > > *** > > #### EPP tabled 248 omnibus amendments weakening privacy, noyb finds > > Axel Voss scored -67 and the 17 lowest scores all belong to EPP MEPs. Only 23 MEPs scored positive, so what will Parliament take into talks with the Council? > > Austrian privacy group noyb today published a ranking of Members of the European Parliament based on more than 1,000 amendments they tabled to the GDPR and ePrivacy parts of the Digital Omnibus, the EU package that would rewrite core privacy rules. According to noyb, the European People’s Party (EPP) is “clearly the worst for privacy protections,” with 248 amendments graded as lowering protections against 24 graded as raising them, for a group score of -224. Only three political groups, the Greens/EFA, the Socialists and Democrats (S&D) and the Left, finished with a positive score. > > In Short > > A privacy group read every change that EU lawmakers have proposed to Europe’s main privacy law and marked each one as better, worse or neutral for people’s privacy. It found that the largest group in the European Parliament, the centre-right EPP, proposed far more changes that would weaken protections than any other group, while the Greens, Socialists and Left proposed more changes that would strengthen them. The Parliament has not voted yet, but its position will decide how much of the current rules on tracking, advertising and AI survives the final negotiation with EU governments. > > What noyb published > > The ranking sits on a new website, gdpr-omnibus.eu [http://gdpr-omnibus.eu], operated by NOYB - European Center for Digital Rights, the Vienna-based non-profit chaired by Max Schrems. noyb distributed it to journalists in a media update sent on October 12, 2026 at 11:22, under the subject line “Ranking: Who in the EU Parliament wants to limit privacy rights?” The website carries a copyright line for 2026 and navigation by country, by political group and through a set of “special rankings.” > > According to noyb, it “analysed more than 1,000 amendments that Members of Parliament (MEPs) have tabled for the GDPR and ePrivacy Directive.” The organisation says it “sorted and graded more than 1,000 amendments for more/less privacy and also simplification,” and that the website offers “a comprehensive grading of every single MEP who has made amendments, searchable by political group and country.” > > The reason given is access. According to noyb, it is “almost impossible” for citizens and journalists to find out what individual MEPs are doing on the file. Amendments in the European Parliament are tabled in committee documents running to hundreds of pages, and no official tool aggregates them by direction of travel. > > Max Schrems framed the exercise in political terms. “Almost every parliamentarian claims to ‘uphold’ people’s rights, but many do the exact opposite. We bring their intentions to the surface and show who is working on behalf of the people - and who is working on behalf of big tech under the cover of alleged ‘simplification’,” he said, according to the media update. > > noyb is not a neutral observer of this file. It has opposed the Commission’s proposal since before its publication, and PPC Land reported in November 2025 that Schrems accused the Commission of “secretly trying to overrun everyone else in Brussels.” The organisation says it has filed around 800 cases against companies including Google, Apple, Facebook and Amazon, and is funded by more than 5,000 supporting members. The ranking is noyb’s own assessment of each amendment, and the grades below are its grades. > > How the score works > > EPP tabled 248 omnibus amendments weakening privacy, noyb finds > > Axel Voss scored -67 and the 17 lowest scores all belong to EPP MEPs. Only 23 MEPs scored positive, so what will Parliament take into talks with the Council? > > > Austrian privacy group noyb today published a ranking of Members of the European Parliament based on more than 1,000 amendments they tabled to the GDPR and ePrivacy parts of the Digital Omnibus, the EU package that would rewrite core privacy rules. According to noyb, the European People’s Party (EPP) is “clearly the worst for privacy protections,” with 248 amendments graded as lowering protections against 24 graded as raising them, for a group score of -224. Only three political groups, the Greens/EFA, the Socialists and Democrats (S&D) and the Left, finished with a positive score. > Add PPC Land to Preferred Sources > In Short > > A privacy group read every change that EU lawmakers have proposed to Europe’s main privacy law and marked each one as better, worse or neutral for people’s privacy. It found that the largest group in the European Parliament, the centre-right EPP, proposed far more changes that would weaken protections than any other group, while the Greens, Socialists and Left proposed more changes that would strengthen them. The Parliament has not voted yet, but its position will decide how much of the current rules on tracking, advertising and AI survives the final negotiation with EU governments. > What noyb published > > The ranking sits on a new website, gdpr-omnibus.eu [http://gdpr-omnibus.eu], operated by NOYB - European Center for Digital Rights, the Vienna-based non-profit chaired by Max Schrems. noyb distributed it to journalists in a media update sent on October 12, 2026 at 11:22, under the subject line “Ranking: Who in the EU Parliament wants to limit privacy rights?” The website carries a copyright line for 2026 and navigation by country, by political group and through a set of “special rankings.” > > According to noyb, it “analysed more than 1,000 amendments that Members of Parliament (MEPs) have tabled for the GDPR and ePrivacy Directive.” The organisation says it “sorted and graded more than 1,000 amendments for more/less privacy and also simplification,” and that the website offers “a comprehensive grading of every single MEP who has made amendments, searchable by political group and country.” > > The reason given is access. According to noyb, it is “almost impossible” for citizens and journalists to find out what individual MEPs are doing on the file. Amendments in the European Parliament are tabled in committee documents running to hundreds of pages, and no official tool aggregates them by direction of travel. > > Max Schrems framed the exercise in political terms. “Almost every parliamentarian claims to ‘uphold’ people’s rights, but many do the exact opposite. We bring their intentions to the surface and show who is working on behalf of the people - and who is working on behalf of big tech under the cover of alleged ‘simplification’,” he said, according to the media update. > > noyb is not a neutral observer of this file. It has opposed the Commission’s proposal since before its publication, and PPC Land reported in November 2025 that Schrems accused the Commission of “secretly trying to overrun everyone else in Brussels.” The organisation says it has filed around 800 cases against companies including Google, Apple, Facebook and Amazon, and is funded by more than 5,000 supporting members. The ranking is noyb’s own assessment of each amendment, and the grades below are its grades. > How the score works > > The arithmetic is simple. According to the methodology note in the media update, “the ranking counts the number of positive amendments and subtracts negative amendments,” producing an overall positive or negative score. Amendments that noyb considered “unclear or neutral are not counted.” > > One limitation is stated plainly by noyb itself: “The relevance of each Amendments (big or small change) is not taken into account.” An amendment that would remove online advertising from the scope of the GDPR counts the same as one that tweaks a deadline. A legislator who tables a single far-reaching change and many minor protective ones could therefore score positive, and the reverse is also possible. The media update says further detail is available on the website, but the captured page does not reproduce it. > > Each entry on the site shows three bars. A green bar counts amendments noyb graded as lowering protection, a grey bar counts amendments it graded as neutral or unclear, and an orange bar counts amendments graded as increasing protection. The final score is the orange figure minus the green one. For the Greens/EFA, for example, 25 positive amendments minus 8 negative ones gives +17, with 47 neutral amendments shown but excluded. > > Group scores > > The group table on gdpr-omnibus.eu [http://gdpr-omnibus.eu] is headed “Privacy score by group” and described as “aggregate sentiment of amendments by political group.” The figures, as published by noyb, are: > > - Greens/European Free Alliance: 8 negative, 47 neutral, 25 positive, score +17 > - Progressive Alliance of Socialists and Democrats: 25 negative, 105 neutral, 37 positive, score +12 > - The Left (GUE/NGL): 12 negative, 57 neutral, 24 positive, score +12 > - Europe of Sovereign Nations: 3 negative, 7 neutral, 3 positive, score 0 > - Renew Europe: 30 negative, 58 neutral, 30 positive, score 0 > - Non-attached Members: 12 negative, 32 neutral, 7 positive, score -5 > - Patriots for Europe: 49 negative, 44 neutral, 24 positive, score -25 > - European Conservatives and Reformists (ECR): 89 negative, 71 neutral, 25 positive, score -64 > - European People’s Party (Christian Democrats): 248 negative, 100 neutral, 24 positive, score -224 > > Added together, the nine rows contain 1,196 graded amendments: 476 negative, 199 positive and 521 neutral or unclear. That total is consistent with noyb’s “more than 1,000.” It is a PPC Land calculation from the published rows, however, and noyb does not say whether an amendment co-signed by MEPs from two groups appears in both rows. On these figures, amendments graded as lowering protection outnumber those graded as raising it by more than two to one, and the EPP alone accounts for 248 of the 476 negative ones, or 52%. > > The neutral column is large. Some 44% of all graded amendments landed there, which means the scores rest on the 675 amendments noyb was prepared to classify. > > According to noyb, “almost all MEPs have made amendments that go in both directions, but the tendency is clear.” The media update says the EPP’s negative amendments include “the limitation of the scope of privacy protections and the proposal of far-reaching exceptions for high-risk AI.” It describes the ECR as having “performed poorly overall” and says the Patriots “achieved a better score, but it was still negative.” > > Schrems drew a comparison across the spectrum. “Overall, the European People’s Party is clearly the worst for privacy protections and a gift to US big tech. When it comes to privacy rights, even the far-right is more ‘centre’ than the conservatives. The S&D, the Greens and the Left are the only groups that overall defend privacy rights,” he said, according to noyb. > > Continue Reading Here from “The individual rankings” : - > > https://ppc.land/epp-tabled-248-omnibus-amendments-weakening-privacy-noyb-finds/ [https://ppc.land/epp-tabled-248-omnibus-amendments-weakening-privacy-noyb-finds/] >

0 comments

Sign in to join the discussion — your thebay.events account works here.

No comments yet.